The catholic church is clear that, in itself it is a good and meritorious thing to donate our organs. What is the true role of a major world religion such as islam in the newly expanding field of organ transplantation. Introduction this paper presents the third part of a research investigation into the three layer structure of bioethical decisionmaking in. The cost of xenotransplantation compared with human organ transplantation 96 the scope of xenotransplantation 97. Should a charitable act be demanded, given that organ transplantation can save the life of another person. At that conference, the transplant community declared the ethical propriety of nhbod on behalf of the u. The ethical implications and religious significance of organ transplantation payment systems. The national organ transplant act nota, in its mandate for the establishment of the task force on organ procurement and transplantation, specifically expressed concern for equitable access by patients to organ transplantation and for assuring the equitable allocation of donated organs among transplant centers and among patients medically.
The presence of a wide gap between organ supply and demand results in a very long waiting time for. Organ transplantation journal of ethics american medical. The ethics of organ transplantation in the islamic republic of iran. The committee makes recommendations to board of directors for changing, creating, or eliminating policies if warranted by ethical concerns. After the compilation of the book islams ruling on organ transplantation by his esteemed father, the grand mufti of pakistan, mufti muhammad shafi, in which he strongly emphasised the impermissibility of organ transplantation, and which was also endorsed by shaykh taqi, m, i read the various arguments in favour of organ. As the demand for organ transplantation far exceeds the organ availability, the transplant program is often saddled with complex legal and ethical issues. Prof of medicinenephrology, shifa college of medicine and cons. Objectives introduction history types of organ transplant guiding principles by who ethical issues involved allocation of the resources certain guideline organ market. The conditions needed for allowing both cadaveric and living donors are discussed. Better off livingthe ethics of the new unos proposal for. Such details are relevant to transplantation because, in islamic countries, fatwas must be passed before this practice is allowed and brainstem death is accepted. Animaltohuman transplants the ethics of xenotransplantation. Islamic ethics of organ transplantation and brain death albar ma.
Attendant with advancements in organ harvesting, preservation, and transplantation come moral issues. The line between voluntariness and conscription in which the interests of the individual are made subservient to the needs. There are certain limitations on what we can and cant do with our bodies. The importance and relevance of religion to medical ethics cannot be doubted. Another question with regard to organ transplantation is whethera bodypart fromthe dead defilesthebodyoftheliving. Why has the fatwa issued by muis on organ donation changed over time. In this paper we simplify and highlight certain key teachings in islamic medical ethics and explore their applications. Islamic ethics of organ transplantation indian journal of. An organ or a tissue obtained from the same individual to which it is. A new methodological approach towards policy formation and implementation is proposed which places ethical concerns at its core. The conference report launched a new era in organ donation, such that brain. Having developed in the crucible of scarce resource allocation for nearly 60 years, the organ transplantation field has much to teach us about balancing equity with utility in the distribution of lifesaving resources. One of the new problems faced by the shia mujtahideen the jurists is the issue of organ donation and transplantation. Mar, 2015 one of the more polarizing policies proposed to alleviate the organ shortage is financial payment of donors in return for organs.
Ethics of organ transplantation journal of the american. We hope that the insights gained will aid clinicians to better understand their muslim patients and deliver care that pays due respect to their beliefs. Extensive efforts have been made to address these problems in different communities. Islam is a holistic religion that takes into account social. Organtransplantationis thusartificiallyconnectedtoa different issue in islamic law, so as to makeanalogy possible. Islam is a holistic religion that takes into account social affairs of man as well as spiritual ones. Historical reflections are discussed as to why muslim thinkers were late to consider contemporary medical issues such as organ donation. Again,thehanafischool is quotedas determining not defiling andthemaliki as claimingthat a humanbeing, aliveordead. Social and religious considerations regarding organ transplantation the shortage of organs for transplantation makes it important to understand why some. A catholic perspective 1 foreword in the words of pope john paul ii, we should rejoice that medicine, in its service of life, has found in organ transplantation a new way of serving the human family. Medical ethics is known for its controversial issues.
Transplantation is an act of transferring an organ, tissue or cells from one person donor to another recipient. Organ organ donation organ transplant shariah tissue vital function vital organ xenograft an organ taken from one member of a species and received by a member of that same species, e. Islamic scholars with an expertise in islam and medical ethics. Contemporary topics in islamic medical ethics journal of. Frequently asked questions united network for organ sharing partnering with your transplant team health resources and services administration, united network for organ sharing pdf. Three british muftis understanding of organ transplantation. Islam and endoflife practices in organ donation for. The islamic o sool or fundamentals of islamic jurisprudence.
Approaching organ transplant in islam from a multidimensional. Modern technology has given rise to a host of legal and theological questions for muslims 1. Successful transplantation of different kinds of organs what began with the kidney has now expanded to hearts, lungs, livers and. Ethics ethical principles in the allocation of human organs. The ethics of organ donation, donation after circulatory. Organ transplantation has been transformed from an experimental procedure at western academic centers to an increasingly common procedure in private and public hospitals throughout the world. Although islamic scholars have debated deceased organ donation many muslims remain unaware of these debates, or of islamic rulings on the issue.
Beyond the core dilemma of just allocation, organ transplantation demands that we agree on criteria for death before taking organs, decide how much risk living donors can fairly assume, identify means for increasing the supply of organs, and devise an acceptable reimbursement plan for posttransplant medical care. Pdf the ethics of organ transplantation in the islamic. In the lancet today, we are publishing a series of three papers to add to the debate about ethical, policy, and clinical issues surrounding organ transplantation. The islamic perception, both shiite and sunni, is examined in relation to organ donation and its various sources. New fatwa published to clarify islamic position on organ. Also includes legislative and social materials, references, and a glossary. Transplantation ethics from the islamic point of view.
Organ donation, fatwa, mufti, bioethics, ulama, fiqh, medical ethics, islamic law, islam, muslims, embodiment, optout, consent. The human body, in life as well as in death, is governed by divine laws in islam. Iran, kidney transplants, medical ethics, organ transplantation, shia islam. Islam has a long history of ethics literature including the subgenre of medical ethics. Organ transplantation is an effective therapy for the treatment of irreversible organ damage. The organ transplant process health resources and services administration also in spanish. These questions haunt the ethics of organ transplantation, and they are newly addressed in the fourteen essays collected in a volume stemming from an interdisciplinary conference held in 2009 at the university of st. The ethical implications and religious significance of organ. Organ transplantation can save many human lives and improve the quality of life for many others. The overview discusses organ transplantation and its history, the process, and ethical issues concerning organ donors and the organ shortage. This paper introduces to the islamic principles of ethics in organ transplantation involving human subject to address issues of religion and religious ethics.
Muslim jurists allowed different forms of bone grafts autograft, allograft and. Ethical considerations related to organ transplantation and. Dorff, professor, american jewish university, chair of the conservative movements committee on jewish law and standards, saving a life through organ donation supersedes the rules concerning treatment of a dead body. Amjid ali strategic partner, nhs blood and transplant organ donation in islamic juridical ethics professor abdulaziz sachedina george mason university ethics of organ transplantation. Ethical and legal aspects of organ transplantation in iran. Eubios journal of asian and international bioethics.
Organ is a fully differentiated structural and functional unit in a human being or animal that is specialized for some particular function. This book analyzes the national debate over organ transplantation in egypt as it has unfolded during a time of major social and political transformationincluding mounting dissent against a brutal regime, the privatization of health care, advances in science, the growing gap. Ethics of organ transplantationteckchuan voo et al aware and informed, and by the provision of simple and convenient procedures for anyone to opt out. A lifesustaining organ whose removal leads to death. Ethical, islamic perspective, legal, nigeria, organ transplantation access this article online. An organ or tissue obtained from a different species, such as porcine valves. Beyond the core dilemma of just allocation, organ transplantation demands that we agree on criteria for death before taking organs, decide how much risk living donors can fairly. The ethical implications and religious significance of. The ethics of organ donation, donation after circulatory determination of death, and xenotransplantation from an islamic perspective.
An organ transplant is a surgical operation where a failing or damaged organ in the human body is removed and replaced with a new one. Oct 16, 2010 islamic bioethical perspective on organ transplantation. Today, most of these nations allow both livingrelated and cadaverorgan transplantation, but they vehemently reject commercial transplantation. The great advances in the technology of organ preservation, immunosuppression, and surgical procedures have resulted in success in saving lives. An organ is a mass of specialized cells and tissues that work together to perform a function in the body. Oct 15, 2011 in the lancet today, we are publishing a series of three papers to add to the debate about ethical, policy, and clinical issues surrounding organ transplantation. The historical background of the islamic jurists views on organ transplantation and the recent fatwas decrees are highlighted. However, these advantages have raised major ethical, policy, and religious problems in organ transplantation. Jun 19, 2019 a leading ukbased muslim scholar has published a new fatwa, or religious edict, around organ donation to bring some clarity on a variety of widely held concerns around the islamic position on whether muslims can donate their organs after death. Saudi j kidney dis transpl serial online 2004 cited 2020 apr 16. The ethics committee aims to guide the policies and practices of the optn related to organ donation, procurement, distribution, allocation, and transplantation so they are consistent with ethical principles. Ethical issues of organ transplantation in islam citeseerx. The kingdom of saudi arabia, the most conservative islamic country, is playing a major role in formulating ethical islamic jurisprudence views and rules in the rapidly expanding field of organ transplantation, and in implementing these new rules in its proliferating centers. The major transplantrelated medical advances in the last century include.
Muslims to conduct their affairs with ihsan compassion. A group of cells in the human body performing a common function. Ethics by an authorized editor of the aquila digital community. Jan 10, 2020 3 this decision provided the possibility to expand organ transplantation projects which included only living donors. Mujtaba quadri assistant dean, clinical administration, assoc. One such question that engaged scholars in the muslim world since 1950s was the issue of organ. United network for organ sharing unos and the organ procurement and transplantation network optn bernat et al. Pdf transplantation ethics from the islamic point of view.
Abstract recent advances in the fields of organ donation and organ transplant have introduced new hope for the treatment of serious diseases. In principle, judaism sanctions and encourages organ, eye, and tissue donation in order to save lives. Principles of islamic ethics various fatwas on the same matter a fatwa is taken seriously if it is given by qualified jurists and is accepted by a significant number of jurists. Transplantation within the framework of shariah mr. This book analyzes the national debate over organ transplantation in egypt as it has unfolded during a time of major social and political transformationincluding mounting dissent against a brutal regime, the privatization of health care, advances in science, the growing gap between rich and poor, and the islamic revival.
South asian islamic scholars with an expertise in islam and medical ethics. The subject of organ transplant has been highly contested within islam. The most important aspects of islamic medical jurisprudence may be the rules on the new methods and techniques provided by tremendous advances in medicine and the moral. Islam and endoflife practices in organ donation for transplantation. Eighth working session states that it is permissible in the shariah islamic law to remove the organ from one persons body and transplant it into another persons body in order to save the life of that person or to assist in stabilizing the normal functioning of the basic organs of that person. Islamic ethics of organ transplantation and brain death. In islam, the permissibility of organ transplantation and donation is not specifically mentioned. However this promise has been accompanied by several issues.
Children, organ donation and islam archives of disease. The islamic guidance on practical issues related to human life in particular can be sought in islamic medical ethics. Jun 15, 2018 the ethics of organ donation, donation after circulatory determination of death, and xenotransplantation from an islamic perspective. The first paper in the series calls on governments to develop selfsufficiency in organ transplantation, which will help to end transplant tourism and organ trafficking. Children, organ donation and islam archives of disease in. I hope i have conveyed the major issues upon which islamic ethics has evolved consensus regarding organ transplantation and some of the more contentious issues over which debate continues amongst muslim physicians. Islamic ethics of organ transplantation indian journal. Today, most of these nations allow both livingrelated and cadaver organ transplantation, but they vehemently reject commercial transplantation. Islamic rulings on organ transplant and organ donation. A priori and empirical investigation concludes that such systems are ethically inadequate.
Ethical considerations related to organ transplantation. Legal, ethical and islamic perspective in nigeria no religion forbids the practice of org an transplantation as a for m of treatment. New fatwa to clarify islamic position on organ donation. In 1990, during the sixth international conference of islamic jurists, the participants discussed the issue of genital organ transplantation. Firstly, the evaluation of organ transplantation in terms of its results related to essentials of faith and to otherworldly life. All the major religions and belief systems in the uk support the principles of organ donation and transplantation. Nephrologist, shifa international hospital, islamabad, pakistan. A minimum level of cultural awareness is a necessary prerequisite for the delivery of care that is culturally sensitive.
Better off livingthe ethics of the new unos proposal for allocating kidneys for transplantation. A history of organ transplantation the medical practice of organ transplantation has grown by leaps and bounds over the last 50 years. Islamic ethics of organ transplantation and brain death albar. Organ donation and islam islamic medical ethics society. Ethics of organ transplantationteckchuan voo et al359 commentary the ethics of organ transplantation. Islamic bioethical perspective on organ transplantation.
588 1624 748 763 299 1501 808 143 1402 619 266 239 395 265 573 367 1280 1362 1296 1432 60 117 658 111 952 1653 1090 1660 350 659 896 49 1254 782 124 885 7 999 1095 1322 742 197 499 1475 481 970 1037 1103 1320